This wouldn't be a true challenge if I didn't step outside of my comfort zone sometimes. When I saw this product sitting in the gas station freezer, I hesitated. Not because I was interested in any way at all, but because I was asking myself if I thought I could even try it, let alone use it to cause a brain freeze. But, the very fact I asked that question let me know I had to give it a try. Cotton Candy flavor...yellow...it truly tasted like a frozen Peep, if such a thing is even possible. I don't know what a Crabby Patty would truly taste like, or Chum from the Chum Bucket...but I can't imagine either being worse than this...but at least it met the basic requirement...it was cold, and before I threw the bulk of it away, SpongeBob managed to give me my next brain freeze!